Think about the last disagreement you had at work that went badly. Not the dramatic one; the ordinary one. A deadline someone wanted moved, a decision you thought was wrong, a colleague who kept taking over meetings. Chances are you handled it the way you usually handle these things, and chances are that was part of why it went badly.
Most of us have one or two default ways of dealing with conflict, and we use them far more widely than they deserve. A conflict style test does not tell you the right way to handle disagreement, because there is not one. What it can do is show you which tools you reach for automatically, and which ones you have quietly stopped using.
This guide is built around our conflict style test, which uses the published Dutch Test for Conflict Handling (DUTCH). It covers what the five strategies are, what each one costs when it becomes a habit, and how to do something with your result beyond nodding at it.
A conflict style assessment measures which strategies a person tends to use when they disagree with someone. The Dutch Test for Conflict Handling (DUTCH) measures five strategies derived from Dual Concern Theory, which describes conflict behaviour as the product of concern for one's own outcomes and concern for the other party's: problem solving, compromising, forcing, yielding, and avoiding. Its authors describe it as a measure of behavioural intentions rather than observed behaviour.
Two concerns, five strategies
The DUTCH comes from Dual Concern Theory, which describes conflict behaviour as the product of two concerns: how much you care about your own outcome, and how much you care about the other person's. The five strategies are what happens at different combinations.
- ✦Problem solving: high concern for both. Look for a solution that genuinely works for everyone.
- ✦Compromising: moderate concern for both. Each side gives something up and you meet in the middle.
- ✦Forcing: high concern for your own outcome. Hold your position and push for it.
- ✦Yielding: high concern for the other person's. Give them what they want.
- ✦Avoiding: low concern for both. Step back from the issue, or do not raise it at all.
No style is best — each has a price
You will find plenty of training material that treats problem solving as the grown-up style and everything else as a failure to reach it. We think that is wrong, and so does the theory. Each strategy is the right answer to some situations, and each one becomes a problem when it turns into a reflex.
- ✦Problem solving is the best tool when interests are not truly opposed, but it is slow and it needs the other side to engage. Used on trivial disagreements, it turns every small decision into a workshop and exhausts the people around you.
- ✦Compromising is fast and feels fair, which is why it is so easy to reach for too early. Splitting the difference often leaves value on the table that a few more minutes of problem solving would have found, and it can teach people that the way to get half of what they want is to ask for twice as much.
- ✦Forcing is right when a line genuinely has to hold — safety, ethics, a decision that is yours to make. As a habit, it wins arguments and loses people. Colleagues stop bringing you problems early, because they know how the conversation will go.
- ✦Yielding is right when you care much less than they do, or when the relationship matters more than the issue. As a habit, it builds quiet resentment, and it deprives the team of your actual view.
- ✦Avoiding is right when emotions need to cool or the issue truly does not matter. As a habit, it lets small problems grow until they can no longer be avoided — and then they come out at the worst possible moment.
The most useful score is often your lowest
People tend to read their top strategy first and feel either pleased or slightly caught out. We would encourage you to spend more time on the bottom of your result. A strategy you almost never use usually points to a whole class of situations you are handling with the wrong tool.
If forcing is your lowest, ask whether there are things you should be standing firm on and are not. If yielding is lowest, ask when you last let someone else simply have their way on something that mattered more to them than to you. If problem solving is lowest, the question is whether you are settling disagreements faster than they deserve. None of these is a character flaw. They are habits, and habits can be noticed.
The avoiding blind spot
One strategy deserves a special warning. The DUTCH's authors describe it as a measure of behavioural intentions rather than observed behaviour, and they are candid that intentions and behaviour do not always match. The gap is widest for avoiding. In the original negotiation study, how much people said they avoided did not correlate with what observers or their opponents actually saw.
The reason is almost obvious once you hear it: avoiding is defined by things not happening. You do not notice the conversation you did not have, or the email you decided not to send. So a low avoiding score is worth treating with some suspicion. The best check is someone else's view. Ask a colleague you trust whether there are topics you tend to steer around. The answer may surprise you.
How precisely to read the five scores
The DUTCH is short: four items per strategy, twenty in total. That makes it quick, and it also limits how finely the scores can be read. The scales' reliabilities in the published study ranged from .65 for yielding to .73 for avoiding, and we show those figures on the result page rather than hiding them. In practice, gaps of less than about ten points between two strategies are inside the instrument's noise.
Two other things are worth knowing. The five scores are independent: scoring high on problem solving does not require scoring low on forcing, and they do not add up to a fixed total. And if all five come out about the same, that usually means one of two things — either you genuinely vary your approach by situation, which is a perfectly sensible way to handle conflict, or you answered at a fairly even level throughout. Only you know which.
Do something with it: replay one disagreement
A result you read once and forget is not worth much. The most useful exercise we know takes about ten minutes.
- ✦Pick one recent disagreement that did not go as well as you wanted.
- ✦Name the strategy you actually used. Be honest; it is often your top score.
- ✦Ask what the situation called for. Was it an issue where interests were really opposed, or one where a better option existed? Was it yours to decide? Did it matter more to you or to them?
- ✦Name the strategy that would have fit better, and one sentence you could have said that uses it.
- ✦Next time a similar situation comes up, try that sentence.
Work is not home, and the test only asks about work
Every DUTCH item sits under the same instruction: when I have a conflict at work, I do the following. That is deliberate. The scale was built and validated as a workplace measure, and your result describes how you intend to handle disagreement with colleagues, managers, and clients.
Plenty of people handle conflict very differently at home. Someone who problem-solves patiently with a difficult client may yield to a partner on everything to keep the evening calm, or force with a sibling in a way they never would with their boss. If your result does not match how you see yourself, check which setting you were picturing. It is worth answering with work in mind, because that is what the scores are calibrated for, and then asking separately whether your habits at home are the same. For closeness and distance in relationships specifically, our guide to attachment styles covers the patterns a workplace scale does not reach.
Using it with a team
Conflict styles are most useful as shared language. A team that has talked about their results can say things like "I went straight to compromise there and I should not have" or "I think I am yielding on this because I am tired, not because I agree," without it turning into an argument about character. That is valuable, and our team view is designed for it.
What the DUTCH should not be used for is evaluation. It is not validated for hiring, promotion, assignment, or performance review, and using it that way is unfair to the person and a legal exposure for the employer. If a team exercise starts to feel like a ranking of who handles conflict "best", stop and reset. There is no best.
Why this is not the TKI
If you have done conflict training before, you may have taken the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument. The TKI is a commercial, licensed instrument whose items are not published, so it cannot be implemented or checked by anyone outside its publisher. The DUTCH measures five strategies from the same underlying theory, and its twenty items are printed in the appendix of a peer-reviewed paper anyone can read. Our test reports DUTCH scales, not TKI modes, and the two are not interchangeable. We chose the DUTCH because you can check every item we used — which, for a test that asks you to be honest about yourself, seems like the least we can offer in return.